Crossed Crocodiles

Tuesday, April 01, 2008

AFRICOM, Democracy, and Senegal

The APS training the Senegalese Navy, November 2007


From AFRICOM's FAQ:
What is U.S. Africa Command designed to do?
U.S. Africa Command will better enable the Department of Defense and other elements of the U.S. government to work in concert and with partners to achieve a more stable environment in which political and economic growth can take place . . .


From the report of an international conference held in Accra in October 2007 PDF: Democratization in Africa - What Progress Toward Institutionalization, I looked up what it had to say about Senegal, since General Ward mentioned it.

General Ward, Commander of AFRICOM, testified before Congress in March, PDF Ward Testimony. He mentioned Senegal several times. I wondered if he had Senegal in mind for a West African regional HQ for AFRICOM. So I thought I would look at what he had to say about Senegal, and compare it to what was said in the report on Democratization. From the report on democratization:

The re-emergence of political monopolistic practices—for example in Senegal and Nigeria—can also lead to severe setbacks in democratic fairness and probity, out of proportion to their institutional capabilities.

. . .

When Senegal’s longtime opposition leader, Abdoulaye Wade, won the presidency in 2000, ending four decades of Socialist Party rule, there were high hopes for a new era of democracy, built on some of the continent’s oldest traditions of pluralism and liberal thought. But increasingly, the aging President Wade drew power and resources into his own hands and those of his family. In the years leading up to Wade’s reelection in 2007, journalists, political activists, singers, and marabouts (Muslim spiritual leaders) who criticized Wade or supported the opposition were subjected to physical intimidation and violence. Critics charge the election was marred by vote-buying, multiple voting, and obstruction of opposition voting.

Despite a lackluster economic performance, Wade was able to mobilize support with corruption—coopting religious figures, civil society leaders, local administrators, military officers, and members of with money, loans, diplomatic passports, and other favors. Now, it is alleged, the octogenarian president is preparing to hand power to his chosen successor—his son. “He has destroyed all the institutions, including political parties. He has taken opposition with him and manipulated the parliament,” a Senegalese democratic activist told me. “People are so poor and Wade controls everything. If you need something, you have to go with him.” The reaction from Europe and the United States (without whose aid Wade’s government could hardly function) has been muted. The activist lamented, “We expected more from the donors,” referring to the defense of principles, not the gift of money. (p.8-9)

. . .

For African leaders, penalizing rural groups or the urban poor is less hazardous than cutting the military budget or divesting state enterprises, which may create large job losses among urban constituencies.


On March 13 General Ward testified to Congress:

IMET funding for Senegal allowed that country to host a regional seminar on Defense Resource Management and conduct a Military Justice Seminar. The IMET program has also contributed to the excellent reputation the Senegalese military has earned during numerous peacekeeping deployments, and continues to contribute to the military’s positive and responsible involvement in civil affairs. Returning Senegalese IMET graduates are immediately assigned to key leadership or staff positions, and their professional attributes make them well-suited to assume leadership positions in international military operations. Sustained support for a robust IMET program is a long-term investment in the future and directly supports long-term U.S. interests.
(International Military Training and Education (IMET) program brings African military officers to US military academies and schools for training (some say indoctrination.) Top countries: Botswana, Ethiopia, Ghana, Kenya, Nigeria, Senegal, South Africa.)
. . .
A lack of FMF (Foreign Military Financing) funding or inconsistent year-to-year distribution can compromise long range objectives, turn our partners towards other sources, and inhibit peacekeeping operations. Senegal, for example, would not have been able to meet its Darfur commitment without ACOTA equipment and help from France.


Granted, AFRICOM is a military combatant command. Still, I don't see anything in what General Ward says that indicates plans to help achieve a more stable environment in which political and economic growth can take place. The only thing the AFRICOM activities in Senegal that he describes seem likely to do is to facilitate military government, as he speaks of military leadership and positive involvement in civil affairs. If the US cared about stability, and particularly about positive political and economic growth in Senegal, it seems that some pressure on Wade to support and strengthen democratic institutions might be appropriate, along with some measurements to gauge actions and progress.

Instead, I suspect Wade seems like an extremely convenient tool, or "partner", for AFRICOM to engage.

The report on Democratization also includes these observations:

Few countries, however, have developed an autonomous domain of civil society that can effectively press politicians for better policies or economic performance. In such countries as Mali, Senegal, Mozambique, Malawi, Benin, Ghana, or even Nigeria, we commonly find that many associations are small, focused in urban areas, reliant on donor funding, or fragmented regionally and ethnically.

. . .

The re-emergence of political monopolistic practices—for example in Senegal and Nigeria—can also lead to severe setbacks in democratic fairness and probity, out of proportion to their institutional capabilities.

Labels: , ,

4 Comments:

  • along w/ ward's mention of IMET training for senegalese officers, he states that "11 of the 14 serving General Officers in the Botswana Defense Force (BDF), as well as the BDF Command Sergeant Major, are U.S. IMET graduates."

    can't find any indication that he ever had u.s. military training, but botswana's new president, lt. gen. seretse khama ian khama, prior to becoming mogae's veep, was the commander of the BDF.

    according to an AFP story tuesday, khama, who is the son of botswana's first president, "has come in for some criticism for a somewhat autocratic leadership style."

    the AP reports

    [blockquote]

    While Mogae may claim to set a standard for democracy in Africa, democracy activists and opposition members here complain about "automatic succession." The Botswana Democratic Party, in power since the former British protectorate gained independence in 1966, virtually anoints the next head of state. The party is expected to continue its dominance in the face of a weak and divided opposition.

    "The danger is that it provides for a dynastic succession which has been the trend since Seretse Khama," said Chris Maroleng from the Institute for Strategic Studies in South Africa.

    [/blockquote]

    will have to investigate what his ties have been to the u.s. military during his political career. for instance, what is his stance on AFRICOM? one of the items his military leadership was recognized for was "playing a pivotal role in developing the army into a professional force," according to a bbc article.

    running out of time to do more research now, but i'll end w/ this sequitur, since khama is a pilot

    photo: A large US military base in the middle of Botswana

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 12:39 AM, April 03, 2008  

  • Very interesting on Botswana. Right now I'm thinking that may well be the Southern African regional HQ for AFRICOM. There was also an article about two Air Force generals named to top spots in AFRICOM, which would fit in with air bases. I don't know anything about Khama's background.

    Thanks for the picture! I was looking at Google Maps and fiddled around seeing if I could find the air base, but since I hadn't a clue where in the country to look, I didn't have much luck.

    There was also this from Wayne Madsen, but I'm not a subscriber:
    AFRICOM HQ reportedly to be located in southern Morocco, near border of disputed and natural gas- and oil-rich Western Sahara. If that is correct, that may be the North African regional HQ.

    Our cable TV recently started carrying France 24, 24 hour news in English. It actually has a certain amount of real news, unlike the celebrity gossip that constitutes most of the US TV news. It featured a clip about training the Liberian armed forces, which it said is being done by two corporations, but only named DynCorp. The corporate employees were not allowed to speak to the press. There was a spokesman from the US military talking about how open and transparently they were doing everything. France 24, speaking about the training, said something along the lines of: this program will soon become part of the US security structure for Africa called AFRICOM. That would fit right in with Liberia facilitating the floating base.

    And I hate to be paranoid, but I am really wondering about google doing a bit of unsolicited filtering or censorship. It would hardly be the first time. I get what is supposed to be their comprehensive alert on AFRICOM. Very recently google seems to be leaving most of the blog mentions of AFRICOM out of their alerts. And the blog citations included are not necessarily the most significant out there. If I do a google blog search, I get citations that aren't coming in the google alerts. I wonder how much news may be "overlooked" as well. But if I do a blog search on ask.com for AFRICOM it looks like I'm getting a lot more in the ask.com search than in the google search. My posts used to appear in the google alerts, and recently they have disappeared, which is also curious. It is annoying if the alerts are filtering or censoring, because I don't see an easy alternative to the google alerts, and they are a handy way of following stories.

    By Blogger Crossed Crocodiles, at 10:54 PM, April 04, 2008  

  • the botswana base is here, not far outside of gaborone. the name of the base is thebephatshwa.

    i saw one article where botswana's foreign minister (2003) stated that

    [blockquote]

    "The US does not own any military base in Botswana. Thebephatshwa air base is wholly owned by the government of Botswana," he said.

    "It was constructed during my term as commander of the BDF, with our own resources, without any assistance from the US or any other country."

    [/blockquote]

    however, where i found out about it was on an AFRICOM thread at the usmc's small wars council forum & military guys there say it was indeed built by the u.s. before apartheid ended in south africa.

    just found an interactive version of the google map at wikipedia that has notes describing what's there.

    that madsen piece is probably about the january story on u.s. military construction near tan tan in morocco, which i pointed out in the comments in that one african loft thread. it had been reported the u.s. was building more infrastructure on some property the moroccan govt had given them some time back & that this was rumored to be either the HQ or a regional HQ for AFRICOM. unless madsen has something new on it or more insight, that story is from jan 21.

    AFRICOM runs a flashy website on the maghreb - magharebia.com. might get a feel for what's current there, but the few times i've visited the english language content hasn't yielded enough to bring me back.

    i've never tried the google alerts or subscribing to any feeds yet. wouldn't be surprised though to hear that their search algorithms just happen to miss critical or even negative coverage on sensitive topics. we know that the AFRICOM folk were rudely jarred from their insular (royal?) bubble by hostile reception across the planet to this new imperial experiment. perception mgmt services are working overtime, trying to control the narrative. definitely seems like the volume of material ebbs more than it flows these days. at least that's my impression - that they're laying low whenever possible to ride the public relations thing out.

    and something i've learned, when using the search engines "AFRICOM" and "africa command" often yield unique results.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 2:50 AM, April 06, 2008  

  • Thanks for the map info! I looked around Gabarone, as that seemed the most likely, but the photo said in the "middle" of Botswana. So I wasn't certain. I was just trying to do a bit of pattern recognition.

    I thought the Morocco business might be what you had written about here and at African Loft.

    I'm also wondering about Ward's trip to Uganda. I know Museveni has longtime US ties. Is he an IMET grad? I can't remember right now, but there is some stuff going way back.

    We've been ordering stuff to ship for the farms for our spring shipping. We ordered a couple of pounds of an heirloom field corn called Big Daddy's. We'll be using it to feed the chickens, and also saving seed. It was sold out in one place, and offering very limited supplies in the other place we could find it. It is hard to get seed in Ghana.

    By Blogger Crossed Crocodiles, at 10:21 PM, April 06, 2008  

Post a Comment

<< Home