Crossed Crocodiles

Sunday, May 20, 2007

Getting it wrong again, the Africa Command and other US Agencies

A quote from Gandhi: “We must be the change that we want to see.”
From a street mural in Esteli Nicaragua.

Once again the US is getting it backwards. The neocons running US foreign policy like to think the end justifies the means. When people say the end justifies the means, they miss the point entirely.

The means you use determine the ends you get. Military means beget military ends, diplomatic means beget diplomatic ends, violent means beget violent ends, democratic means beget democratic ends. There are a few exceptions, but if you base your planning on assuming you will be the exception, it is the same as basing your financial planning on assuming you will win the lottery.

UPI reports that Africom is seeking 25 percent of the billets in the new command to be filled by the departments of State, Agriculture, Commerce, Health and Human Services and other agencies. Those agencies, who have generally seen their budgets slashed, are not eager to anti up. Why should they turn over scarce resources to the Pentagon whose budget is gargantuan in comparison to theirs? Supposedly:

AFRICOM will be untraditional in that its staff will focus not on preparations for military action in Africa but instead on stabilizing governments, training their militaries, encouraging their economies and helping governments address destabilizing problems like AIDS and famine. AFRICOM's aim is less to be prepared for military conflict than it is to avert the possibility of it.


Recent actions against the government of Somalia and Somali citizens
, and the alliance with Nguema in Equatorial Guinea, put the lie to these claims of helpful intentions.

Army Gen. Bantz Craddock, EUCOM commander appears to understand what is needed. As a member of the US armed forces, I am sure he is doing his best to fulfill his mission. Unfortunately, the mission itself is flawed. As he says:

"Very few (of Africa's) challenges can be solved by the department of the military," Craddock told reporters Friday. "It's Health and Human Services, Commerce, Department of Justice, Energy, Agriculture.


Diplomatic and technical problems need to be addressed with diplomacy and technology. If the US wants to address the real challenges in Africa, it needs to do so with skilled diplomacy, working through the State Department, allied with other departments of the US government who can bring their expertise. The US must show by example it believes in what it preaches. Military assitance yields militarized results.

One way to understand Gandhi's words is that in order to effect change, one must assume the nature of the change one wishes to effect. In other words, the word justify is irrelevant, the means determine the ends.

Labels: , , , , ,

3 Comments:

  • On a more realist/cynical level, has the U.S. military as an arm of of the USG ever acted in an altruistic manner?
    Not in my memory of the past 40 years.

    By Blogger Dr Doom, at 11:24 PM, May 20, 2007  

  • don't be fooled by the stress on the civilian component of AFRICOM. looking at craddock's quote,

    "AFRICOM will be untraditional in that its staff will focus not on preparations for military action in Africa but instead on stabilizing governments, training their militaries, encouraging their economies and helping governments ..."

    one of the key words to focus in on is "stabilizing."

    in the (really weak) congressional research service report for congress issued last week, titled "Africa Command: U.S. Strategic Interests and the Role of the U.S. Military in Africa," (available at the secrecynews website) the author writes:

    The Department of Defense, identifying instability in foreign countries as a threat to U.S. interests, issued DOD Directive in 2005, defining stability operations as a "core U.S. military mission" that "shall be given priority comparable to combat operations."

    and then when you read the footnote attached to that line, it reads

    DOD defines stability operations as "military and civilian activities conducted across the spectrum from peace to conflict to establish or maintain order in States and regions." [bold is mine]

    so what they're talking about is using both civilian & military components to establish & maintain order answerable to u.s. interests.

    one process will be through "professionalization" of african militaries, which means training & grooming officers indoctrinated to u.s. military protocol etc...

    not a new trick. the u.s. has made big use of it throughout the southern half of the americas for decades, w/ the notorious school of the america's being commonly refered to as the "school of the golpes." walter lafeber, writing in his book "inevitable revolutions: the united states in central america" of the birth of the SOA, shared this prescient story

    When a Mexican official learned that the United States planned to give special training to Latin American officers, he said, "Give me the names of those first 60 students, and I'll pick your presidents in Latin America for the next 10 years." Delesseps Morrison, Kennedy's ambassador to the OAS, responded that Latin America would indeed be fortunate if these officers did become the future leaders of their countries. The Mexican official, however, was closer to the truth than Morrison. Between 1961 and 1966, the military overthrew nine Latin American governments.

    no doubt, africa certainly has experience w/ coups. and many african nations have had long relations w/ the u.s. military. (there's an african center for strategic studies annex currently in addis ababa -- of all places -- instructing military and civilian leaders on "good governance and democracy promotion." one can get an idea of how seriously the u.s. takes such values by their locating the academy in a dictatorship, an irony not lost on those who pay attention to such matters.) but, given the wilsonian emphasis on democracy promotion currently in rhetorical favor w/ the u.s. power elite, military dictatorships don't play well in the global public eye. especially now that africa is in the spotlight as a booming oil producer.

    so it's necessary for the hybrid approach, coordinating efforts between the state department and a host of acronyms (USAID, IRI, CIA, etc...), to try to control governments from the inside by imposing u.s.-style ideas of democracy & governance.

    make no mistake, though, the mission both components are tasked w/ are, in the end, the same.

    as for the humanitarian missionary zeal w/ which advocates for AFRICOM would have us believe, never forget that, in his days, leopold II was known as the great philanthropist. it's a con as old as empires...

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 12:07 AM, May 22, 2007  

  • dr. doom - I tried to think of an exception out of curiousity. I thought briefly about Kosovo, but of course the Trans-Balkan pipeline plays into that.

    b real - I read something this past weekend that mentioned the school of the americas, and I thought to myself - oh no, not that. Control and exploitation do seem to be at the heart of Africom.
    A number of my friends and some family members have made careers in the US military. Out of respect for these people I am sometimes careful in my wording. In general these military people I know have a better understanding, and stronger commitment to US constitutional principles than a number of civilians I know.
    But that doesn't change the policy coming from the top. The overall aim of Africom looks like traditional control and exploitation. And with Bush/Cheney at the helm, it could hardly be anything else.
    I appreciate all the information you provide!

    By Blogger Crossed Crocodiles, at 9:17 AM, May 23, 2007  

Post a Comment

<< Home